Friday, December 9, 2016

Sex Trafficking-Why there are no viable methods to stop it

Human trafficking, specifically sex trafficking, is a very important problem that ought to be addressed in some way. However, it is improbable that any measures taken to put a stop to it will be successful. Among these ideas that the class mentioned were suggestions to close borders or tighten border security, and making prostitution legal so as to be able to better regulate it through institutions. While there are understandable arguments to each one of these ideas, I do not believe that either would have a good outcome. Specifically, I would contend that legalizing prostitution would have more negative effects than positive because it would set a bad example for all individuals in different ways, it would not end forceful prostitution, and it would set a dangerous precedent for future legalization of unacceptable practices. 

The vision that I had in my head during the entire conversation was, if prostitution was legalized and all of a sudden the practice was prevalent, above ground, what would parents say to their kids when they inevitable asked about it. Kids are curious about everything! This would be a horrible thing to explain to little girls that some girls who grew up were selling their bodies and this is now an acceptable occupation. All of these years that feminists have tried to fight or women's rights would vanish. I understand that there is a feminist argument that women should be able to choose to do whatever they so please with their bodies. However, I would contend that in most cases, resorting to prostitution is far from a free-willing choice. Furthermore, what does it say when a government allows men to legally pay women to give their bodies? There is nothing okay with prostitution. There is an unequal balance of power between the prostitute and the person buying the service and that will undoubtedly follow the people into the rest of their daily lives. Prostitutes will feel inferior and men will look down on the women who "choose" to do this, as they do now. Legalizing the practice will certainly not fix this. 

Going off of that previous statement, legalized prostitution will also not end the horrors of sex trafficking. There will still be poor treatment of these people even when the institutions are "checking in on it". Putting this in perspective, right now prostitution is illegal but obviously the practices still occur in copious amounts. So, making the wrongful treatment or conditions of/for prostitutes illegal does not automatically mean that this won't still happen. That is just the nature of life. Theft is also illegal and that happens daily with the perpetrators often getting off, similar to many other crimes. Even tightening institutions won't pose a solution in my opinion. Using another example, Boston has some of the strongest police and criminal institutions compared to the rest of the world and yet Whitey Bulger was able to walk the streets instigating violence and several murders for decades with the FBI knowing. People are corrupt. Institutions can be corrupt. There is no way this will ever not be the case. 

The third factor of legalizing prostitution that's scary is the precedent that it might set. If the government were to make something so morally wrong and publicly controversial a legal occupation, what could come next? There is a tremendous danger in making practices such as these legal. The scariest to me is that after decades of this being legal, prostitution would become a social norm. It wouldn't be looked upon as this awful situation in which either women are forced into it or they lack self-respect. I think this would have tremendous implications in aspects of social life. At the end of the day, any type of human trafficking is a disgustingly horrific thing and our institutions obviously need to do a better job at preventing and stopping it. But, the ways in which they could do this are slim and in my opinion, probably not viable. 

5 comments:

  1. I agree, I have such a hard time understanding why legalizing prostitution will eliminate/lessen sex slavery. There are legal ways for employers to hire and pay workers, but from the pie charts we saw, there are still huge numbers of slaves that work in factories and houses. Why would making it legal stop those who force people to be sex slaves? Clearly they don't care about the law anyway and want to exploit people for person gain.
    Can you think of any ways to lessen sex slavery in the US? I can't think of anything that would greatly lessen it here.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I completely agree with you that legalizing prostitution would not bring any positives to the situation of human/sex trafficking. You made a good point when saying that prostitution would just become a social norm. Once it becomes that, there is not going back to trying and stoping it. I don't think the amount of people being trafficked would decrease by legalizing prostitution.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Women's bodies being commercialized and sold as a sex symbol is nothing new to us, and it is not prostitution that started this. Gender equality is ideal, but it surely will not happen in the near future because women are automatically born into a position below men in our social hierarchy. The point I was trying to make in class but didn't know how to say is that in an ideal world a woman wouldn't have to worry about the stigma of her profession (whatever it may be) because she wouldn't be pressured by historically negative connotations regarding the role of females in society. In a "fair" world, a prostitute's profession shouldn't have to be looked down on, but of course, a "fair" world is impossible. I understand that historical connotations about women are important and won't just go away with the legalization of prostitution. However, there is a problem with perpetuating the notion that women who are prostitutes are criminals; I don't know what the solution to this is but I think this is where the problem lies. I tried to think of it from their perspective; this may be the last option they have in providing for families or making a living, and making prostitution illegal puts the blame on prostitutes when society is to blame for putting the woman on a lower-level status in the first place. Overgeneralizing to say that prostitutes lack self-respect ignores the larger issue in society. We can't assume prostitutes are the victim or the criminal, which is in part why this problem is so difficult when debated as a legal issue. I agree with you that this problem seems impossible to fix.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry just realized how long this is-- this topic gets me going. Hope it makes sense

      Delete
    2. I understand what you're saying. I think that some women willingly chose to be prostitutes and that's her choice. I don't think that it should be shamed. The majority of the time male strippers aren't shamed but women strippers are. That is the problem with our society today. In my opinion legalizing prostitution has nothing to do with lessening human trafficking. To me it seems like a completely different debate. Do you think that it would affect the number of people trafficked?

      Delete